Key Positional Battles & Competitions for Places in the England Squad
As the Six Nations Championship looms on the horizon, the air at Twickenham Stadium and across the Rugby Football Union’s high-performance centres is thick with more than just winter chill—it’s charged with competitive intensity. For Head Coach Steve Borthwick, the period between campaigns is defined by critical evaluation, where every training session and club performance is a live audition. The composition of the England national rugby union team is never static; it is a dynamic puzzle where form, fitness, and tactical nuance dictate the final picture.
This constant evolution is the lifeblood of elite sport. Understanding the key positional battles provides unparalleled insight into the strategic direction of England Rugby, forecasting not only who will pull on the famous white jersey but how the Red Rose intends to play. From the set-piece foundations laid by the forwards to the creative sparks in the backline, each contested jersey tells a story of ambition, resilience, and the relentless pursuit of excellence. Here, we analyse the most compelling competitions for places that will define Steve Borthwick’s selections for the Guinness Six Nations and beyond.
The Engine Room: Lock Forward
The second row is the cornerstone of any pack, demanding a blend of lineout mastery, destructive tackling, and relentless work rate. This position is about partnership, and the competition to partner the indispensable Maro Itoje is fiercely open.
The Incumbent & The Challenger: George Martin’s monumental performances during the Rugby World Cup, particularly his defensive demolition job in the semi-final, announced him as a world-class enforcer. His physicality is a guaranteed asset. However, the return to fitness of Ollie Chessum presents a fascinating dilemma. Chessum’s athleticism, lineout skills, and surprising agility for his frame offer a different, more dynamic profile. This battle is a classic clash of styles: Martin’s uncompromising power versus Chessum’s all-court mobility.
The Wildcard: Keep a close eye on Nick Isiekwe. His ability to cover both lock and blindside flanker provides invaluable versatility for the matchday 23, a factor Steve Borthwick highly prizes. A strong run of form for Saracens could force him into the starting conversation.
Practical Tip for Analysis: Watch the lineout success rates and tackle dominance in key Premiership and European games. The player who consistently commands the air and stops opposition momentum at source will have a significant edge.
The Pivotal Decision-Maker: Fly-Half
The number 10 jersey dictates the tempo, strategy, and attacking shape of the entire team. It is the most scrutinised position in rugby, and for England Rugby, it is currently a multi-faceted debate.
The Leadership & Control of Owen Farrell: Even with his international future a topic of discussion, Captain Owen Farrell remains a monumental figure. His game management, defensive organisation, and peerless kicking from hand and tee are foundational. If available, his experience in high-pressure fixtures like the Calcutta Cup or clashes for the Millennium Trophy is immeasurable.
The X-Factor of Marcus Smith: Smith offers a contrasting, instinctive threat. His ability to break the gain line, create something from nothing, and play with a high tempo asks different questions of defences. His development as a game manager continues, and his performances in the Autumn Nations Series showed increased maturity.
The Emerging Force: George Ford’s sublime tactical kicking and calm demeanour make him a proven Test match winner. When on song, he can dissect a defence with his boot as effectively as others do with their hands.
This is less a straight head-to-head and more a selection conundrum defined by opposition and game plan. Does Borthwick opt for the control of Farrell or Ford, or unleash the spark of Smith? The potential for a 10-12 axis featuring two of these players also remains a compelling option.
The Front Row Foundation: Loosehead Prop
The battle at the scrum is the game’s primal contest, and the loosehead prop is the spearhead. This position requires a unique combination of raw power, technical expertise, and, in the modern game, surprising athleticism in open play.
The Vice-Captain’s Mantle: Ellis Genge has grown from a powerful impact substitute into a leader and a cornerstone of the pack. His ball-carrying is crucial for gaining front-foot ball, and his scrummaging has become consistently dominant. As a vice-captain, his place seems secure, but his role—starting finisher or finisher—is key.
The Technical Maestro: Bevan Rodd’s rise has been built on exemplary scrum technique and a high work rate around the park. He represents the new breed of prop: mobile, skilled, and durable. When the set-piece requires absolute stability, Rodd is a formidable option.
The Resurgent Force: The return of Joe Marler from international retirement adds fascinating depth. Marler’s experience and renowned scrummaging artistry, particularly his ability to disrupt opposition tightheads, provide a specific and highly effective weapon in Borthwick’s arsenal.
The selection here may well be dictated by the specific opponent. A focus on set-piece solidity might favour Rodd or Marler, while a game plan requiring go-forward ball from the first minute could see Genge start.
The Breakdown Battle: Openside Flanker
The openside flanker is the team’s chief disruptor, the hunter at the breakdown. In the era of the ‘jackal’, this player’s ability to win turnovers and slow opposition ball is non-negotiable.
The Incumbent’s Class: Tom Curry, when fit, has been a permanent fixture for years. His engine, tackling ferocity, and breakdown intelligence are world-class. His recent injury history, however, has opened the door for others to state their case.
The Form Contender: Sam Underhill’s resurgence has been a highlight of the domestic season. Rekindling the destructive form that made him a global star in 2019, his tackle technique and ability to win crucial penalties make a compelling argument for a recall.
The Versatile Option: Like Itoje in the second row, this position benefits from players who can cover multiple roles. Jack Willis, now plying his trade in France, remains a breakdown specialist of the highest order, while Ben Earl’s explosive carrying from the base, though often deployed at number eight, offers a different interpretation of the flanker’s role.
Steve Borthwick values turnover wins above almost all other defensive metrics. The player who demonstrates the most consistent, legally astute threat over the ball in the weeks leading into selection will have a powerful claim.
The Midfield Conundrum: Inside Centre
The number 12 channel is the defensive fulcrum and a critical link between forwards and backs. The choice here shapes both the defensive system and the backline’s attacking patterns.
The Power Game: Ollie Lawrence embodies the modern, powerful inside centre. His ability to crash over the gain line, fix defenders, and offload creates quick ball and opportunities for those outside him. He is a direct, physical solution.
The Playmaking Alternative: The selection of a second playmaker at 12, such as Marcus Smith or Owen Farrell, shifts the tactical approach significantly. It creates dual decision-making points, encourages a wider attacking shape, and places a premium on distribution and kicking options. This was a theme explored during the Autumn internationals.
The Defensive Organiser: Manu Tuilagi, when fit, remains a unique force. His presence alone commands a two-man defensive focus. However, the role has evolved, and the competition now hinges on whether Borthwick prioritises gain-line dominance (Lawrence/Tuilagi) or tactical flexibility and playmaking depth (Smith/Farrell).
This decision is intrinsically linked to the fly-half selection. A Lawrence-Smith partnership differs vastly from a Farrell-Lawrence axis, showcasing the multi-layered nature of England Rugby’s selection process.
The Backfield Conundrum: Fullback / Back Three Utility
The back three—two wingers and a fullback—requires a blend of aerial prowess, lethal finishing, and positional intelligence. Competition here is perhaps the most wide-open.
The Fullback Focus: Freddie Steward has made the 15 jersey his own with his peerless ability under the high ball, a vital asset in Test rugby. However, the desire for a more attacking counter-attacking threat from deep has seen Marcus Smith and others trialled here. Steward’s reliability is weighed against the potential for greater offensive spark.
Wing Warriors: On the wings, the blend is crucial. Does England opt for the raw pace and finishing of players like Tommy Freeman or Cadan Murley, or the all-round power, kicking game, and experience of Jonny May or the emerging Immanuel Feyi-Waboso? The Six Nations rugby environment, often dominated by territory and aerial duels, may favour those with a more robust all-round skillset.
The Utility Value: A player like Henry Arundell, with his game-breaking speed and ability to cover wing and fullback, is a potential ‘game-changer’ for the matchday 23, even if not starting.
For a deeper understanding of how players emerge into these fierce battles, explore our guide to the player pathway from academy to the England team.
Navigating Selection: What Steve Borthwick is Looking For
Understanding these battles requires seeing them through the lens of the head coach’s philosophy. Steve Borthwick is a meticulous planner who values specific attributes:
- Set-Piece Excellence: A non-negotiable. Dominance or solidity in the scrum and lineout is the ticket to selection.
- Defensive System Adherence: Players must be intelligent, communicators, and ruthless in executing the defensive pattern. Turnover threats are prized.
- Kicking Strategy: Whether a forward executing a 50:22 or a back launching a contestable kick, every player must be a competent and willing part of the tactical kicking plan.
- Versatility & Impact: The value of a player who can cover multiple positions or deliver a definitive, game-altering impact off the bench is incredibly high in the modern 23-man game.
- Big-Match Temperament: Performance under pressure, especially in arenas like Twickenham during the Six Nations Championship, is the ultimate test.
For ongoing analysis of how these factors influence the final squad, revisit our central hub for in-depth squad analysis.
Conclusion: A Squad Built on Competition
The health of England Rugby is measured by the depth of its talent pool and the ferocity of its internal competition. The battles outlined here—from the scrum to the backfield—are not merely about individual glory; they are the processes that forge a tougher, more adaptable, and ultimately more successful national team.
As Head Coach Steve Borthwick finalises his plans for the Guinness Six Nations, every carry, tackle, and kick in the club arena carries weight. The players who seize their moments, who address the specific tactical demands of the Red Rose, will earn the right to represent their nation. For fans, this competitive cauldron is what makes the build-up to an international campaign so captivating. It promises a squad not of comfortable incumbents, but of proven warriors and hungry challengers, all united by the ambition to restore England to the summit of the game.
Stay with The Rose & Crown for all the latest news, expert insight, and squad announcements as England men's rugby team prepares for its next challenge.*
Reader Comments (0)